Gallium nitride (GaN), as a core segment of the third-generation semiconductor industry, is an essential component for fast charging, AI servers, and power supplies in new energy vehicles. While the market is experiencing rapid growth, cross-border patent disputes are frequent. The recent chain of lawsuits between InnoX and Infineon spanning China, the U.S., and Germany over the past two years stands as a textbook case for domestic semiconductor companies navigating patent battles in global markets
This patent battle began in 2024, spanning three core markets—America, Germany, and China—where both parties filed lawsuits against each other and simultaneously initiated patent invalidation proceedings, resulting in a prolonged back-and-forth lasting nearly two years.
In March 2024, power semiconductor giant Infineon filed the first lawsuit against Innosek in a California court in the U.S., alleging that multiple gallium nitride devices infringed on its core device structure patents. In July of the same year, Infineon escalated the efforts by initiating a U.S. 337 investigation and applying for a customs exclusion order, aiming to directly cut off Innosek's U.S. shipments. Meanwhile, a Munich court in Germany issued an interim injunction prohibiting Innosek from exhibiting or selling the disputed products at European trade shows, effectively restricting the entry of domestic GaN products in both Europe and the U.S.
In the face of overseas litigation, in January 2025, Innolux filed a counterclaim in Suzhou Intermediate People's Court, suing Infineon for multiple gallium nitride fast charging and power supply devices infringing on its two underlying invention patents, with a total claim of 20 million yuan. Infineon immediately filed a declaration of invalidity for the patent in question. After examination, the State Intellectual Property Office rejected all invalidation requests and confirmed the stability and validity of two core patents of Innolux, laying the foundation for domestic litigation.
·Chinese market: Suzhou Intermediate People's Court has made a first instance judgment, determining that Infineon has infringed two invention patents of Innolux. The court has ordered Infineon to immediately stop selling, promising to sell, and importing related infringing products, and to compensate Innolux for a total economic loss of RMB 10 million. At the same time, the court issued two interim injunctions against Infineon, which will take effect immediately on the day of service.
Infineon disagrees with the injunction ruling and applies for reconsideration to the Supreme People's Court. On June 12, 2026, the Supreme People's Court officially issued a review ruling, rejecting all review applications from Infineon and maintaining the ban. Infineon cannot appeal again. This means that multiple gallium nitride power semiconductor products from Infineon will cease sales in China from today onwards.
·US market: On May 7, 2026, the ITC committee made a final ruling confirming that the current gallium nitride power device products of Innolux do not infringe on Infineon's related patents and can continue to be imported and sold in the United States without restrictions. The committee only determined that the historical old products that have already been discontinued by Innolux constitute infringement of a patent of Infineon, and the relevant ban does not have a substantial impact on the existing business.
·German market: In 2025, the Munich District Court in Germany ruled in the first instance that Insec had infringed on Infineon's patents and banned its sale of related GaN products in Germany. In June 2026, the Munich District Court once again ruled that Insec had infringed two intellectual property rights (one patent and one utility model) of Infineon, prohibiting Insec from manufacturing and selling infringing products in Germany and ordering it to pay damages. This is the third and fourth time that InnoSeco has lost in a series of lawsuits.
However, InnoSeco subsequently announced that according to the ruling of the Munich court, the currently sold gallium nitride power device products do not fall within the scope of patent protection claimed by Infineon and are not restricted in Germany. The court only found that some old models of products that have been delisted were infringing
Patent layout is both a "moat" and a "weapon". Overseas enterprises should not only focus on domestic patent layout, but also apply for PCT simultaneously for core components and underlying processes, covering the core sales regions of the United States, European Union, and Southeast Asia. Attention should be paid to building a high-quality patent matrix around core technologies in order to play a balancing role in cross-border patent litigation.
Infineon was the first to sue InnoSeco in Germany and the United States, and InnoSeco chose to bring the main battlefield back to China to launch a counterattack. This proactive countermeasure strategy ultimately led to a decisive victory on the Chinese battlefield. At the same time, during the litigation period, InnoTech redesigned its products to avoid the protection of Infineon patents, and was ultimately confirmed to not infringe in overseas markets, or only the old products were involved in infringement, ensuring the normal sales of its main new products overseas.
In the global semiconductor industry competition, intellectual property is both a shield and a sword. Advance global patent layout and new product infringement search. Only by avoiding design can we take the initiative in the international patent game!

News